You may be trying to access this site from a secured browser on the server. Please enable scripts and reload this page.
Turn on more accessible mode
Turn off more accessible mode
Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content
Turn off Animations
Turn on Animations
Join Now
BOOKSTORE
ABOUT CAI
My CAI ▾
My Profile
My Organization
My Demographics
My Password
My Memberships
My Designations
My Orders
My Classes & Events
My Online Learning
Sign In
Sign In
Chapters
Find A Chapter
Chapter Trade Shows
Benefits from Your Local Chapter
CAI Career Center
Local education and networking opportunities.
Advocacy
Advocacy Priorities
Community Association Law & Lawyers
CAI Public Policies
Advocacy Resources for Members
CAI Advocacy Blog
Take Action Today!
Legislative Action Committees
Resources for Legislators
All the latest from Federal Affairs, Grassroots Activity, Research, Legal and Community Association Issues.
Learning Center
Education for Managers
Education for Homeowners
Education for Business Partners
Online Learning
Webinars
CAI Career Center
Professional Credentials
Research Library
Publications
Events
Exchange: Online Communities
Gain knowledge and experience with our many educational offerings.
Community Managers
MANAGEMENT COMPANIES
Education
Events
Webinars
Chapter Trade shows
Professional Credentials
CAI Career Center
Job Market
Directory of Credentialed Professionals
Publications
Find a Service Professional
Exchange: Online Communities
Industry Data
Everything you need to take your career to the next level.
Homeowner Leaders
Find A Chapter
Chapter Trade shows
Find a Service Professional
Directory of Credentialed Professionals
Exchange: Online Communities
CAI Career Center
The Board Leadership Development Workshop
Publications
Research Library
Webinars
Events
Civility Pledge
Resources critical to your association's operations, management and governance.
Business Partners
Marketing and Advertising Opportunities
Find A Chapter
Chapter Trade shows
Events
Professional Services Directory
CAI Career Center
Education
Webinars
Professional Credentials
Publications
Exchange: Online Communities
Find new and exciting opportunities to grow your business and further your education.
It looks like your browser does not have JavaScript enabled. Please turn on JavaScript and try again.
Fast Search
Annual Conference
Law Seminar
M-100
Directory of Credentialed Professionals
Professional Services Directory
FCAR
PCAM Case Study
Best Practices
Code of Ethics
Reserve Study
Join Now
Shop
About CAI
My CAI
My Profile
My Organization
My Demographics
My Password
My Memberships
My Designations
My Orders
My Classes & Events
My Online Learning
Featured News
Featured News
CAI Announces President & Board of Trustees
CAI Named Best Workplace for Commuters
CAI Awards Highest Credential to Association Professionals
Featured Tools
Featured Tools
Exchange
Join your peers on CAI's members-only community. Log on using your CAI website password to ask questions, discuss ideas, search resources, strengthen your network, share best practices and help your community thrive.
Learn More
Professional Services Directory
Find the professional service providers you and your association need. When you need professional support, look no further than these CAI members.
Learn More
Directory of Credentialed Professionals
Your one-stop resource to find CAI-credentialed professionals.
Learn More
Job Market
Are you an employer looking for professionals to hire? Or are you a job seeker looking for a new career opportunity? This should be your first stop.
Learn More
Multimedia
Multimedia
Grassroots Advocacy
Serving on an Association Board
The Board Leadership Development Workshop Promo
Government & Public Affairs
See All
INDUSTRY DATA
2020 National and State Statistical Review
Learn more
351,000
community associations in the US.
$7.19
trillion value of homes in community associations.
Advocacy
Take Action Today!
Currently selected
Contribute to a LAC
Issues Advancement Fund (IAF)
Advocacy Resources for Members
Sign Up for Advocacy Alerts
Find Your Elected Officials
Constituents in your Communities
Share your connections with elected officials
CAI Advocacy Ambassadors
CAI #VoteforHome!
#STOPSB300: Reasons Why SB 300 is Bad for Homeowners
Page Content
SB 300 is Unconstitutional
:
It violates the
Montana Constitution Section 31
: No ex post facto law nor any law impairing the obligation of contracts, making any irrevocable grant of special privileges, franchise, or immunities, shall be passed by the legislature. The Montana Supreme Court in numerous rulings has declared that HOA and condominium covenants are a contract between the association and the owners
.
The proponents of SB 300 are in Litigation with their HOA:
SB 300 was drafted by a family who were the exception to all the homeowners in the subdivision they bought a house in Red Lodge to use as a VRBO. Their association all (except this family) voted in favor of an amendment to clarify the covenants on the property, resulting in a complete ban on short term rentals. The attorney for the family, Stephanie Baucus, drafted the bill language and has been leading the efforts for its passage. This court should determine the outcome of the case, not the legislature.
I
ncreased Expenses on Homeowners:
It will be difficult and costly to track homeowners' individual set of rules based on their homes purchase date. This cost will be borne by all the homeowners in the community. Further, the unconstitutional nature of SB300 will cause legal challenges by associations. Legal fees will be borne by the homeowners.
Decrease in Property Values
:
Homes in community associations are generally valued at least 5-6% more than other homes and 90% of
people surveyed
say their association's rules protect and enhance property values (62% or have a neutral effect (28%); only 4% say the rules harm property values. *
Healthy and Safety Concerns:
Communities would not be able to enforce maintenance to ensure community health and safety issues like sprinkler system, dryer vent maintenance. Communities would not be able to enforce rules related to maintenance of community lighting, occupancy limits, installation of wind turbines and towers (of any size and installed by anyone without concern of safety).
Vacation Rentals:
Communities would not be allowed to have a community conversation about how to handle vacation rentals in their communities to ensure the preservation of community character and protection of property values.
Access to Mortgage Lending may be Negatively Impacted:
If communities have more than 50% of the homes owned by investors, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac will not underwrite loans in those communities according to their federal guidelines. If a community association chooses to adopt a related to the investor/owner ration, it will be unenforceable to some of the owners.
SB 300 is Patchwork Legislation:
The problem with attempting to alter property rights in a hurried and piecemeal fashion is that no thought is given to all the ramifications of the legislation or to the effect on other areas of the law.
talkingpointsSB300
Community Associations Institute
Currently selected